15 Most Valuable Nickels 

15. 1872 Shield Nickel

14. 1873 Shield Nickel

13. 1873 Shield Nickel

12. 1874 Shield Nickel

11. 1875 Shield Nickel

10. 1876 Shield Nickel

9. 1877 Shield Nickel

8. 1878 Shield Nickel

7. 1879 Shield Nickel

6. 1879 Shield Nickel

5. 1880 Shield Nickel

4. 1881 Shield Nickel

3. 1882 Shield Nickel

2. 1883 Shield Nickel

1. 1883 Shield Nickel

The Top 10 Valuable Indian Head Pennies in History